Sunday, November 14, 2010

Aston Villa 2-2 Manchester United

Another away draw, and whilst this time the game couldn't be described as " forgettable" United's performance, for the first 80 minutes anyway, once again could. This season just isn't happening and unless Rooney returns to the kind of form he showed last season when he makes his return hopefully next week, it's increasingly hard to see it doing so.
With no Giggs again due to his hamstring, and no Scholes due to his booking on Wednesday night, once again we were found badly wanting in the creativity stakes. Before the sides were announced i would have took a draw, due to our current away form and the players mentioned missing. But when i saw Villa's midfield four, i honestly thought even with our current indifferent form we should have been capable of gaining the three points to keep us on the rent boys tail.
I should have known better. The first half was a cagey affair where Villa's young side felt their way into the game and United once again struggled to produce anything resembling a coherent display. I thought we would enjoy long periods of domination of the possession but though we had short periods of control the longer the half went on the more Villa got into it and gained the confidence to go in at half time having spent the last five minutes of the half looking the more likely side to score.
United had the better of what chances were actually created in that half with the best falling to Berbatov who having been put through by Hernandez but managed to miss the target. What has happened to the Bulgarian, he had a half decent game on Wednesday but yesterday he was back to the player of no confidence that we saw at the end of the last season.
I felt sorry for Hernandez, he didn't have a great game but the service to him was almsot non existant. Carrick and Fletcher didn't boss the midfield as i had expected but i can't attach much blame to Fletcher, just as last season he has had to play almost every game and thus lost his sharpness. In his best seasons Fletcher was often rested, especially before the big games. We are so short of quality in central midfield now Fergie can't afford to rest him. Hopefully Cleverley will come back in the new year and give us a bit more depth here or we will almost certainly finish the season as we did last year, running on empty.
I had the horrible feeling that if Villa came out with a bit more belief in the second half we might be in for a torrid day. Unfortunately that is precisely what they did and the worst did follow as they took us apart in a fashion we haven't really seen for a long time. If they had been four or five up before our last ten minute fight back we couldn't have complained.
There were no arguments on the penalty decision, it was a clumsy challenge from Brown and a definite penalty. The wonder was that it had taken them so long, having missed a couple of great chances as well as hitting the woodwork. Ashley Young made no mistake and i thought that was that, the way we had played the only team i could see scoring another was Villa.
Fergie then made a double substitution bringing off the front two and replacing them with Macheda and Obertan. I'll hold my hands up, i thought that was as good as handing them the three points. And when the first thing Macheda did was lose it and set Villa up on a counter attack which saw Downing fire in a cross that Albrighton couldn't miss from i was wondering whether this was going to turn into one of those hammerings we get now and then.
At last United started to at least a little bit threatning as Ferdinand had one shot cleared off the line, but i was worried we would be caught on the break throwing men forward. United went forward again and this time the industrious Fletcher outwitted the Villa devence with a back flick that Macheda fired home from inside the box to make amends for his mistake at the start of Villa's second goal. Villa then almost killed us completely when Downing cut inside and hit a thunderous shot which had Van Der Sar well beaten but it just flew over. United went straight to the other end and the first great piece of play from Nani as he beat two men in front of him and put in a great cross to the back post for Vidic to superbly head back across Friedal to amazingly level up the scores.
Fergie now brought Smalling on for Park as United tried to steal the three points. It wasn't that far from happening as a great run from Obertan saw him force Friedal into a great save, even if he didn't know much about it. A United win would have been a serious miscarriage of justice nut that was the last real chance of the match. So mixed emotions at the end, jubilation and relief at the rescue of a seemingly lost cause and a realisation that as things stand we just are not good enough to win any of the trophies that matter.

Mark Ogden reports on Rooney's probable return next Week and the questions about his future still to resolved. I don't think anyone really knows what the score is on this front. There a lot of sceptics out there, regarding his long term future at United, that much is certain. The Mirror reckons Rooney's teammates are still unhappy with his implied criticism of some of them and will have to patch it up with them. If there is an ounce of truth in any of that, there may well be new depths to plumb as the season progresses, as there is nothing worse than a split dressing room.

The Irish government again denies it is in talks to conduct a bail out of it's economy as the rumours keep on coming. As the melftdown of the Irish economy continues, the age old Irish problem of immigration rears it's head as it's young people despair of a bright future in their homeland. Fintan O'Toole argues Ireland can still have a bright future but only if it uses this crisis to sweep the old guard away and thoroughly reform its democratic structures. There must be a reckoning for its political elite and it's cosy come corrupt relationship with those greedy property developers who have led into this crisis.

Johann Hari demolishes the promises and record of Nick Clegg and predicts that he will lose his Sheffield seat at the next election. I don't know enough about his constituency to know how precarious his position is, but i would have thought he would be in big trouble. All i can say is good, he deserves to lose his seat. Maybe the lib dems can return to being the centre left party that it was and should be.

Matthew d'Ancona warns the coalition that the student protests were a sign of things to come, although he thinks that last weeks protests won't have done the government any harm, protests to come might not paint them in so favourable a light. This isn't how John Harris sees things and reminds us of some of the promises that David Cameron made before the election, there are almost as many hostages to fortune as Clegg in that. list.
Will Huton also thinks this is a sign of things to come and warns that demonstrations against the poll tax and the Iraq war were the beginning of the end for Thatcher and Blair.
Benedict Brogan wonders if Cameron will learn anything from the spate of memoirs to have come out recently. Are the goverment already thinking about their leagcy. The most interesting fact to come from the article is the assertion that they have already decided to govern as if they will be a one term government, enact reforms rather than run for re-election, or slash and burn.
From there point of view it tmakes total sense and the biggest indictment of new labour is it was permanently running for re-election and doing whatever would least alienate the electorate rather than trying to radically reform the rotten state of democracy left by 18 years of tory rule.
Peter Oborne hoped Cameron would be the man to clean up parliament after the stench of new labour's period i office. He is a disappointed man so far as he describes our legislative chamber as rotten to the core.
Peter Hoskin lists ten points you need to know about the welfare white paper.

Edward Conway comments on the the state of flux that is the present state of the global economic system. He is another who thinks the system of the last 35 years is shattered and just as the gold standard was replaced by Breton woods and that was replaced by the Thatcherite consensus we have just watch collapse a new consensus emerge. He argues that this may take time as it may not emerge until China have replaced the US as the global economic superpower.
A system where the freedom of capital is curtailed would be one of the main starting points in an ideal world as far as i am concerned. What an irony if it was a totalitarian regime that allowed a proper democratic supervision of the interests of our so called financial elite to emerge.
Paul Mason argues that we must find a new settlement to return to a rerun of the 30's and all the misery that floowed on from that decade. He sees no reasonto be cheerful after the G20 that put a a sticking plaster on the disagreements currently in evidence.
Nick Cohen comments on the disgrace that was vodafone's deal with HMRC. If freedom of capital was to be curtailed, corporate tax evasion and offshore tax evasion may be a problem that a proper centre left government will be able to get on top of. He is right to attack our establishments love affair with big business and the wordl of the rich and famous.

Suu Kyi released by the Burmese Junta at last calls for freedom of speech as the basis as a new democratic start for the country. It will be interesting to watch how much support she actually now receives after being freed. After reading John Kampfner's Freedom for sale she will be swimming against the tide as southern Asia's curent trend is for a preference for economic wealth over democratic freedoms. So whilst we may laud her, if the Burmese generals play it canny and follow the Chinese model they could retain power and gain enough support from the population to keep them in the gravy.

Johnny Vegas is inetrviewed in the Independent ahead of starring in Chekov's Cherry Orchard for Sky arts.

Richard Williams reviews The Promise: The darknes on the edge of town story. As one of my favourite if not the favourite of Springsteen albums i was always going to get this, but that review means sooner rather than later.

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Manchester City 0-0 Manchester United

Well that was one forgettable game of football, so forgettable i have forgotten it already. I'm not complaining, i would have took a point before the game, so i'm happy enough. I wasn't really sure what to expect from City, though after seeing their game against the rent boys earlier in the season, i shoud have known what to expect. That is a team that is not going to challenge, never mind win the title this season.
The starting line up was either a pleasant surprise or utterly predictable, depending on how believable you thought Fergie's claims of being unable to know what his starting line up would be until just before kick off. I usually take his pre match injury talk with a pinch of salt, but i was a little worried last night i have to admit. Of course i should have known as we lined up with as strong a line up as posible in the circumstances.
I was a liitle surprised and a liitle worried the way the game started. I can't remember the last time that City have kicked off against us and then proceeded to have almost total possession for the first ten minutes. They didn't create anything and as soon as United got their foot on the ball a more normal pattern of play established itself with United seeing at least as much of the ball as City. One thing City did manage to do last night though was shackle Scholes pretty effectively. Unlike last season where they just got everybody behind the ball, last night they tried to press us further up the pitch. The return of Tevez helped them in that repect as you got to hand it to them, it worked.
To say it was a dull first half would be doing a diservice to the word dull. One shot on goal a piece was the limit of excitement, at least United managed to create ours in open play as opposed to City's effort Tevez's free kick that Van Der Sar comfortably pushed out for a corner. I thought we were slightly the better team and the only team that had threatened to create anything during open play. But the fact was for all our decent midfield play we weren't good enough to unlock their defence. I thought Park's renaissance came to halt last night, he didn't have a bad game, but he didn't produce in the areas that we needed him to. In the first half especially, he kept drifting inside, finding himself in good positions but was unable to maximise the opportunity. Oh for a fit Ryan Giggs last night, with Scholes suspended for Saturday i hope he will be back for the Villa clash or our lack of creativity could well come back to haunt us again.
The second half was a slightly better spectacle, for a United fan anyway, but we never really threatened to open them up and the only real chance was Brown's cross that Berbatov connected cleanly with but ended up straight at a grateful Joe Hart. City really reverted to type, under Mancini that is, with a second half display that was even more negative than last season's encounter at the boo camp. They spend all that money in the summer and play against a United team in slow decline and without Rooney and the approach the game like that. Is Mancini really a better manager than Mark Hughes, i know who i would sooner have managing my team anyway.
So back to four points behind Chelsea and another hard game on Saturday and injuries galore, we needed to win one of these game in my view to try and keep the presure on the rent boys, the pressure is on.

Van Der Sar wasn't too happy claiming City were only ever interested in the point whilst United at least tried to go for the three. James Lawton claims the reality of last night was the exposure of the limits to both clubs title ambitions. I can't really argue with too much of that, the United of 2006-2009 would have ground out the three points last night i'm sure of that. Daniel Taylor in his five things we learnt last night puts his finger on one of our problems at the moment, we are not the same without a Rooney in his pomp leading the line or at least in the starting line up. We all know we are a little short of the quality needed to lead the title charge we we saw in that three year title run.

Mark Ogden claims that Fergie won the mind games before last nights encounter with his claims of a virus decimating our playing staff and then naming as near to our strongest side as possible. I think Ogden is claiming a bit too much on Fergie's behalf there, it's not as if City changed their approach to the match. They played the same way they always do against the big sides under Mancini.
Whether there was a bug or not, the team slection problems will not go away, with Scholes suspended, Evra and Rafael defintely out and who knows where Giggs is on his hamstring recovery, he has to find a team able to go to Villa park and try and get the three points to keep us close to Chelsea. It was a bit worrying to hear that Fletcher had an ankle problem before last night's game.

Jeremy Warner reports on the Bank of England's governor Mervyn King's quarterly report update. Warner interprets the speech as crunch time for the world economy and he could have added the coalition's economic policy. David Prosser reports on the questions about the governors political neutrality. There may have been more questions if Ed Balls had won the labour leadership election. David Blanchflower writes about the problems of unemployment for the unemployed themselves with the misery of Marx's reserve army.
The financial markets have been swept by rumours of a Greek style bailout of the Irish economy, as it goes from bad to worse.

There are fears that the coalition's universal welfare benefit may have to be delayed as HMRC's IT system may not be up to the task. What a surprise that isn't.

Simon Jenkins writes about the hypocrisy of British reltions with China as trade trumps human rights and just about everything else. We just aren't self sufficiently wealthy enough to be pontificating to anybody anymore. We probably lost any moral high ground that we ever had anyway with the charade over WMD and the invasion and occupation of Iraq. Bagehot reports on how Tony Blair got around the problem in his dealings with China during his premiership.
I don't think Blair and new labour ever had this embarrassment though. I would love their bluff to be called, but i just can't see it happening. From what i have ssen so far of the coalition or the tory part at least, is a continuation of the love in with the world of big business and the city.
The Guardian report that the world economic situation is worrying the Chinese authorties who think the Americans are themselves to blame over the economic plight. Everybody seems to recognise the imbalances between the US and Chinese econmies and the need to rectify them but there is nowhere near any kind of consensus about how we are to get there or even where "there" is.
The Chinese trade surplus grew last among amongst rising exports and imports as the tensions to let the yuan appreciate grow ahead of the G20 summit. Robert Peston uses his blog to ask if China's surplus matters, i would have thought that everybody realises that it does. The problem with dealing with it is that you end up rewarding countires who have ran there econmies badly, ie us and the US and would end up punishing countries who have managed their econmoies well, the Chinese and Germans. You can see why they might not see the fairness of this. Faisal Islam thinks the Chinese are already paving the way for a lessening of economic ties with the US as it is losing faith in the attractivness of the dollar. This is the report of the Chinese credit agency Faisal Islam mentioned.
Obama can see the way the wind is blowing as he visits south east Asia, but with the Republicans resurgent and a upsurgent tea party behind them what can he actually do.

Classic Charles Mingus

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Stop satnav

It would seem the man City fear most is guess who, their nemesis on more than one occasion, the ginger prince.They are obviously right to fear him, though it does put the quality of our squad into question, that we are still relying on a stalwart who is almost 36. The man himself is looking forward to tonight, you can't win everything he says, but when you don't win them, there are certain teams you hope don't beat you to those titles, who could he mean. Evra is also keen to build things up, telling City they never beat us. Alas, in the 90's that was the case, but this decade we have had a few disasters against them. He is also happy with the way United plan to face the future by going with youth against City's plans to buy success. I would go along with that, but for the fact it's a strategy enforced on the club by our debt laden owners, not a progressive Barca style ambition. Whether the young Norwegian turns out to be the goods, who knows.
Fergie gets in on the act describing the increasing intensity of the derby, but whilst it's an important game and whilst City are now to be taken seriously after all that Arab money has been poured into the club, Chelsea are still the team to beat. He can't help but have a go at them can he, he is not impressed by the way they have been carried away by their new found wealth, Daniel Taylor thinks he doesn't hide his dislike the modern day Manchester City. He declines to say anything about City's involvment in the Rooney affair.

Andrew Cole reveals he thinks United's current crop of strikers can be as good as the treble seasons when Rooney gets back to fitness and hits his form. Besides Tevez he doesn't think City's imports match up. We probably just shade it, but only if Rooney does come back fit, in form and more importantly interested. I think Silva is a good player, but he is pretty similar in style and position to Tevez. You need forwards who compliment each other as well as click as Cole says the treble side's did.

Talking of the treble season, the legend who will forever have a place in every United fans heart Ole Gunnar Solskjaer is to take up the reigns as manager of Norweigan side Molde FC. What a servant that man has been for this club. We all would love to see him back at the club in the future in some role, there has got to be one ex player who will be able to come back to the club to manage it one day, so why not him.

If Reina is for real, saying he is unsure whether he will stay at Liverpool past the end of this season, i would expect us to be connected with him for the rest of the season. I'm not sure about him myself, he is a good goalie, but is he a great one, i don't see that myself.
It is a big decision replacing Van Der Sar, needless to say, but with the presnt team about to break up and a new team to be built, it becomes even more important to get the right man. Which is why Fergie could well go for somebody with his experience. Whether he would want to come to a club in a rebuilding phase with no money, who knows.

Jonathan Wilson ponders the importance of Carlos Tevez to Manchester City in another of his tactics columns. Whilst i don't doubt he is a very good player, he isn't a special talent. If they had a Drogba or an in form Torres alongside Tevez you would be talking championship potential. It still amazes me, when i think of the big transfer fees they have payed for average players when they would have been better at times waiting for a Rooney or a Torres. I mean anybody could see Adebayor was a luxury player at Arsenal who doesn't turn up half the time.

The bank of England is expected to raise their growth forecasts but some members are uncomfortable with the governors backing of the coalition's startegy of cuts as rocky times lie ahead. As this long article in Prospect magazine by Channel 4's Faisal Islam tells us, the MPC are split over the merits of a further of QE as well. I would have thought that this isn't welcome news for Osborne as that is basically his plan B as far as i can see if growth does dip as consequence of his aggressive cuts.
It seems to me the opponents of QE have a point, it does seem like the return of the funny money policies that the credit crunch revealed, this time it's the central banks indulging in the pratice to try and wish away the funny money toxic debts left us by the banks and hedge funds.
As Simon Jenkins wrote at the time it would have been better if the central banks had just given the elctorate a certain amount of money and told them they had to spend it, and spend it within a certain amount of time to get the economy going again and return confidence to the economy. At least that money would have been spent productively as far as the real economy goes. By the end of that article you just realise voodoo econmics are still with us, monetarists still rule the world. As Larry Elliot wrote in The gods that failed, the city and the financiers always seem to come up smelling of roses and as rich if not richer than before, however much they fuck up. And yet we have a goverment attacking benefit fraud which is a pin prick in comparison to the mess bank bailouts and cutting the public sector, which we are told is unproductive. What the fuck is our financial system then, it certainly seems to provide a nice killing for the suits in the city but what does it do for all us idiots that just put up with this shit.
At the end of the day we may as well fall back on Keynes and kick start the economy using big public work programmes, but that would be state intervention for the good of ordinary people, not keeping our financial masters happy. China and the Asian tigers must be laughing that the future economic leadership of the world is being handed to them on a plate.

Hamish McRae describes why the talk of the return of a modern day gold standard looks attractive to some, with most commentators thinking the US policy of QE is just another from of currency depreciation, but he argues that would be looking backwards. Mind you he doesn't seem to be much of a visionary as to what we should do in the future. Though China being at the centre of it, is probably a prerequisite of what will emerge.

James Purnell shows the paper thin differences between new labour and it's coaltion opponents as he describes his efforts at getting Gordon Brown interested in a universal credit system. Peter Hoskin of the Spectator argues there is a broad consensus on the reform of the welfare state, there are differences to be sure, but the broad outline is similiar. I support a simplification of the system and i would go to a citizens minimum income, an old lib dem policy that i shouldn't think Clegg and his fellow orange book acolytes would be very keen on, which would not be the same thing as the universal credit that both sides are speaking off and which will probably end up condemning the poorest parts of our society to paying the price for the governments, central banks and our financial systems three decades of wrong headed policies.
Hopi Sen argues why he supports the aims of Ian Duncan Smith, but thinks the sums will not add up and the treasury will have him doing their dirty work for them as they will not deliver the sums he will need to make his policies work. Mary Riddell joins in the cheerleading for IDS.
Steve Richards is not impressed by the coalitions direction arguing the facts do not support their claims that the cuts will actualy improve public services. Amen, whichever ex labour minister claimed they are the heirs of Blair wasn't far off the mark.

Alexander Linklater argues against decrimilising drugs in this Prospect article. I don't agree, he never mentions the damage the war on drugs has done to our economies, the money spent on drug law enforcement, the drug money sloshing around the financial world and the damage done to sink estates in this country and around the world.

Simon Schama outlines his vision for the future of the history that is taught in our schools. I wouldn't have guessed that most academy schools don't even teach it, that stinks. As for his list of what every child should learn, it's pretty reasonable, but i would have to include the fight for our liberties and the democratic reform of these islands not just in that list but at the top of it.

Music
Cherry Ghost - Beneath this burning shoreline: The follow up to his debut Thirst for romance doesn't mark amy musical progression, but if you liked that, he has served more of the same. 

Demdike stare - Forest of evil: If you like your techno atmospheric and creepy, even, this is for you.I like it, but it's not music to get excited to.

Eli paperboy reed -  Roll with you: A top album is this, the second album from a couple of years ago. It's retro i suppose but some of the neo soul of the last few years has been top notch.

Lloyd Miller and the Heliocentrics - Lloyd Miller and the Heliocentrics: I can listen to this endlesly, a superb piece of modern jazz with varying degrees of eastern influences. Excellent.

Pocohaunted - Make it real: I have to admit i had to listen to this a few times for me to get into it, but it was worth it. I love the funky experimentalism of it. This is a more tune based commercial sound for them apparently, well it works, though i don't think they will be breaking any singles charts with it.

UNKLE - Where did the night fall: This is another pretty good album, i liked their last effort, War stories but this does improve on that as it works better as a whole.